5 Valentine’s Day Marketing Ideas That Build Loyalty

Valentine’s Day works better as an engagement moment than a sales sprint, so the best Valentine’s Day marketing ideas focus on connection rather than just transactions.

Most brands default to the standard playbook: red graphics, stock photos of roses, and a generic discount code. The problem is that these campaigns blur together, and once the holiday passes, those customers often disappear.

In this guide, I’ll share Valentine’s Day marketing ideas that focus on participation and list growth. You’ll learn how to build a campaign that actually increases loyalty, rather than just cutting into your margins.

What Most Valentine’s Day Campaigns Miss

Most Valentine’s Day campaigns focus on price when they should focus on involvement.

When every inbox is flooded with “20% Off” deals, your discount stops looking special. It’s just noise. Since Valentine’s Day is inherently emotional, it’s the perfect chance to ask for interaction rather than just a transaction.

The numbers prove it. Salesforce found that 80% of customers consider the experience a company provides just as important as its products. Plus, NRF data shows a massive shift toward gifting “experiences” over physical goods.

Campaigns that invite participation, like sharing a story or playing a game, tap into that desire for connection. Instead of a quick sale; you’re building a relationship that lasts longer than the chocolate.

5 Best Valentine’s Day Marketing Ideas for Engagement

Ready to build a campaign that lasts? Here are five practical ways to shift your focus from discounts to deep engagement.

1. Partner With Another Brand Instead of Competing Alone

Co-marketing is the smartest way to get new eyes on your brand without blowing your budget.

When you partner with another brand, you’re not shouting into the void but instead getting a warm introduction to a whole new group of people who already trust your partner. It’s a lot more effective than running a cold ad.

Take the collaboration between Airbnb and LEGO. They teamed up to offer a night in the LEGO House. It was fun, creative, and got everyone talking.

By leveraging each other’s fans, they created a buzz that wouldn’t have been as popular on their own.

You don’t need a LEGO-sized budget to do this, though. To keep things simple, I recommend using RafflePress.

RafflePress is the best WordPress plugin for viral giveaways. It allows you to build fun contests using a drag-and-drop builder, so you don’t need to hire a developer to make it look good.

You can use it to run a branded giveaway collaboration where everyone wins. And the great thing is you can set it up, so entrants have to follow both you and your partner to enter. That way, you both get the leads, and the prize feels twice as valuable.

2. Use Valentine’s Day to Collect Real Customer Photos

User-submitted photos build trust faster than polished brand visuals.

Valentine’s Day is inherently visual. People already document their moments, gifts, and friendships. If you can get them to share those with you, it feels personal and authentic.

Research backs this up. Shoppers are often 85% more likely to buy a product after viewing user-generated content (UGC).

Plus, this content is a goldmine for later. Once you have these photos, you can reuse them in your emails, ads, and social posts all year long.

A perfect example is The Body Shop’s #SendingAKiss campaign. For Galentine’s Day, they asked followers to post a selfie blowing a kiss to a friend.

It was a fun way to celebrate friendship while showing off their makeup products.

However, running a contest like that manually is tough. You have to constantly refresh Instagram to track the hashtag. It’s easy to miss entries.

That’s why I use the “Image Submission” action in RafflePress.

It lets you collect user-submitted photos directly inside your giveaway widget. keep everything organized.

3. Stop Sending the Same Valentine’s Message to Everyone

Treating your entire list the same limits engagement.

Not everyone connects with romance-focused messaging. If you blast a “Romantic Dinner for Two” offer to someone who is single or not interested, you risk annoying them.

People shop for all kinds of reasons. Spending on friends, co-workers, and pets makes up a significant portion of the total holiday spend. If you ignore these groups, you leave money on the table.

Marketing data shows that segmented email campaigns result in 14% higher open rates than non-segmented campaigns. Instead of guessing, just ask them.

RafflePress handles this perfectly with its “Polls & Surveys” action. You can ask a simple question like, “Who are you shopping for this year?” You can then offer a small prize or extra entries in exchange for their answer.

Whether they say “My Partner,” “My Dog,” or “Myself,” you get valuable data. You can tag them in your email marketing service. Then, you can send a targeted campaign that actually converts.

4.  Convert Last-Minute Shoppers With a Shipping Countdown

Late shoppers want reassurance more than pressure.

We’ve all been there, realizing it’s February 12th, and you have nothing planned. For these shoppers, the biggest barrier isn’t the price, buy the fear that the gift won’t arrive on time.

If you just scream, “Hurry! Sale Ends Soon!” you’re adding to the noise. But if you provide a clear timeline, you provide a solution. Clear deadlines reduce anxiety and actually help people make a decision.

For this strategy, I recommend using SeedProd.

SeedProd is a drag-and-drop WordPress website builder trusted by over 1 million websites. You can use it to create custom WordPress themes, custom landing pages, and custom WooCommerce stores without writing any code.

You can use SeedProd to build a landing page with a countdown timer specifically for your Valentine’s offer. Instead of counting down to the end of the sale, set the timer to count down to your Shipping Cutoff.

This gives your customers the certainty they need to click “Buy” right now without worrying if they’ll show up empty-handed.

5. Use Valentine’s Day to Bring People Back Again

The real value of Valentine’s Day is retention, not one-off sales.

It’s common to see a spike in sales in February, only to have those customers ghost you by March. If you don’t have a plan to bring them back, you’re renting your revenue, not building it.

The best way to fix this is to turn that gifting moment into a referral engine. If someone had a great experience buying a gift from you, they are prime candidates to tell their friends.

You should look into specific referral marketing ideas to keep the momentum going.

I recommend using the “Viral Refer-a-Friend” action in RafflePress for this. It’s a powerful way to multiply your reach without spending more on ads.

When a user enters your giveaway, RafflePress gives them a unique link. If they share that link and a friend clicks it to enter, the original user gets bonus entries. Then, that new friend gets their own link to share.

This creates a self-sustaining cycle where one lead turns into three, and three turn into nine, doing the heavy lifting for you.

You can run a post-holiday “Share the Love” event to ensure your momentum continues long after the holiday is over.

Valentine’s Day Marketing FAQs

You might still have some questions about how to pull Valentine’s Day marketing off for your business. Here are answers to the most common questions I get about running these campaigns.

You don’t have to shout the loudest or offer the biggest discount to win Valentine’s Day.

In fact, the best campaigns are usually just the ones that are the most fun. When you invite people to play along, by sharing a photo or tagging a friend, you create a connection that sticks. That’s worth way more to your business than a one-time transaction.

These strategies help you keep those customers long after the holiday is over.

If you’re ready to build your own engagement campaign on WordPress, RafflePress makes it easy to get started in minutes.

You may also find the following guides helpful:

• Valentine’s Day Giveaway Ideas to Win Hearts & Minds
• Exit Intent Popups: How to Turn Lost Traffic into Sales
• How to Create FOMO Notifications for Your Giveaways

If you liked this article, please subscribe to our YouTube Channel for RafflePress video tutorials. You can also find us on Twitter and Facebook.

Stacey Corrin Writer

Stacey has been writing about WordPress and digital marketing for over 10 years and on other topics for much longer. Alongside this, she's fascinated with web design, user experience, and SEO.

See Full Bio

WordPress SEO Digital Marketing Content Marketing SaaS Copywriting